Bay Shore Manor

I appreciate the professionalism of the management team Absolutely amazing! I've really enjoyed living at this apartment because of the friendly staff, great unit options, amenities, and neighborhood. Parking garages a huge plus. I appreciate the carpeted hallways, Clean building. Quiet complex. Landscaper is great. Snow contractor reliable. Super cares. Wonderful lighting. Laundry machines need to be larger!

Manor is nice. Elv and Rub are wonderful caring positive staff. They are extremely welcoming, and take so much pride in living here. It was wonderful to see, and my husband I were so pleased. The grass, trees, are kept really nice. The atmosphere, living grounds both drew us in. It's so quiet. Last night we had excessive heat, but called Elvy, and he said Mr. Toad called him 10pm and I see they are working with an electrician this morning at 8am. Staff is responsive. We used to live in a house and it was too hard for my husband and I to fix everything. We appreciate every effort and we are happy to live here

The community is very nice and green, in good location, so close to main street. Near supermarket, restaurants, town, beaches, railroad, fire island. South Shore University Hospital is so close, my commute is fabulous! Management is to the point, attentive, and quick to respond to inquiries. Email is efficient. The hardwood floors are beautiful. The apartments are spacious and have abundant closet space. A downside is the air conditioning must be supplied. The hallway and carpet are professionally steam cleaned at least twice a year which is cool. There was never been any additional fees which has always been a pleasure.

I've been in my building managed by benart for nearly 3 years now . I feel I’m in good hands. Had to reach out to them on the phone a few times. The last time, they were curt with me but they get the job done even if they don’t give you a long phone call or email. I do wish that they would set up a system for packages but admit it’s probably too difficult. I used to be on Clinton, Saxon, Brook, third Avenue. So, since pandemic, too much traffic so I dislike driving, so it’s super convenient for me since train is there and easy access to street parking, or private lot or garages which is amazing especially for the location. I am a fan of online payment option and electronic leases too.

My wife and I lived here prior to 1998. We transferred to another apartment around 2005. We would not have stayed here since 1998 or transferred to another apartment if we both didn't value Bay Shore Manor. Is everything perfect, no. But the property gives us pleasure, warmth, smiles, nature, a great feeling every time we come home. The property manager is fair, caring, reasonable, the PM practically lived here 3 or 4 months. They perform repairs and upgrades every year, whether it's lighting, parking lots, garages, carpet, cameras, landscaping.

These apts are in terrible condition and dirty. The rent is cheap for a reason, you’re gonna regret moving here…

Leased 1 bedroom for Jan 15th. Elvy is great. Rubie is also so nice. Great team. I have a 2nd floor apt overlooking beautiful trees, shrubs, grass, sky, sun. The view is so serene calming, charming classic layout. Radiator heat was a bit over heated. We cracked a window for a little air. The indoor garages are wonderful & easy. The dumpsters are slightly inconvenient for garbage but the plus side is there are no incenarator garbage room so clean. Hallways were prestine when I moved in but then snow ice melt made them messy. They said they usually vacuum once a week. So far so good!

Super bright lights. The light above the door is a really nice addition. I'm really enjoying the new cameras in the parking lot as well as the new signs. Laundry rooms look so much better. Ed, is such a great super. Thanks for the cleaning the leaves and grass until 10pm before Thanksgiving and Christmas. I'll never forget it!

Parking is tough, when it rains always flooding 4th Ave limiting parking and walking to building. I got my vehicle keyed 1st 2weeks, spit on vehicle. Noise upstairs constantly dropping heavy items. Stomping as they walk upstairs..No insulation or soundproofing...can hear every word. It was a nightmare for sleep and peace. Front door constant banging no one holds door..don't rent on 1st floor. Floors were already scratched I see why they want rugs on floors.

This building is very old and severely run down. The smell of mildew when entering the building was overwhelming. The stairwell looked like it hadn’t been vacuumed in weeks. The kitchen was very small, not much counter space at all and the cabinets had dead roaches and mouse droppings in them. The cabinets are also very outdated and covered with a layer of sticky grease buildup and filth. The outdated appliances were worn out from years of use and need to be replaced. When I turned the kitchen faucet on, there was practically no hot water pressure at all. The bathroom is also very small and the tub was very old, it looks like they spray painted it to hide the age and stains from years of use instead of updating it. The laundry room was also dirty and smelled like raw sewage. No parking lot, street only. Do not waste your time looking at these apartments, I can’t imagine any of the other apartments are any better.

it's bad, they never maintain the apartments I lived 2 years

Went to visit the apartments it was nothing like the photos it was like something out of a horror movie. Dirty and disgusting. They have the nerve to show these filthy out of date apartments.

A wonderful team. Beautiful community. Make sure you rent a new ceramic renovated bathroom. The kitchen cabinets are well made. They have cool NYC style backsplashes. Garage Parking is sold out?

The new management is excellent and there has been lots of great changes.

I appreciate hard work and dedication. Edwin is great. He has done a wonderful job making Bay Shore Manor a new and improved community!

Living at Bayshore Manor, is a wonderful place. The apartment have very large rooms, there plenty of living space. It is private, quiet and peaceful. There is Bayshore Train- Station down from the corner. There is also public transportation close by. Bayshore Manor is a great place to live.