Which NYC Borough Is Right for You?

When you think of New York City, you might first picture the bustling streets of Manhattan. However, the Big Apple goes beyond iconic landmarks like Times Square or Central Park. In fact, it extends throughout four other different boroughs, each with its own unique charm and culture.

If you're searching for an apartment in NYC, it’s worth expanding your horizons beyond Manhattan. Another borough, whether it be Brooklyn, Staten Island, Queens, or the Bronx, might better suit your budget, personality, or way of life. But how do you know which one to choose?

In this article, we’ll help explore each of the five boroughs listed below, including their cost of living, neighborhood options, and more, to help aid your NYC apartment search.

• Manhattan
• Brooklyn
• Queens
• The Bronx
• Staten Island

Manhattan

Manhattan offers the quintessential New York experience. With towering skyscrapers, pedestrian-filled streets, and food trucks on every corner, Manhattan is the go-to area for visitors to get their taste of the Big Apple. However, despite its heavy tourist presence, it’s also a place that over 1.6 million New Yorkers call home.

About the Manhattan lifestyle

The Manhattan lifestyle epitomizes the fast-paced nature of city life. Here, you’ll find people embarking on adventures no matter the time of the day, whether they’re commuting to an office job, heading to a Broadway show, or grabbing a quick bite to eat at a trendy restaurant. If you’re seeking a constant thrill and the convenience of having everything within arm’s reach, Manhattan may just be the borough for you.

Cost of living in Manhattan

The average monthly rent in Manhattan is $3,938, making Manhattan one of the most expensive cities in the United States. This is no surprise, considering all the luxuries Manhattan has to offer. With endless public transit options, walkable work commutes, and entertainment/dining on every corner, it’s no wonder the cost of living is so high. However, if you’re willing to compromise on space and amenities, you can still find affordable options in Manhattan.

Depending on whether you’re living alone or with roommates, here’s what you can expect to pay for Manhattan rent:

• Studio: $3,165/month for 443 Sq Ft
• One bedroom: $3,938/month for 598 Sq Ft
• Two bedroom: $5,291/month for 796 Sq Ft
• Three bedroom: $6,583/month for 992 Sq Ft

Best neighborhoods in Manhattan

Manhattan is home to several residential areas, each with its own reputation and appeal. If you’re set on renting an apartment in Manhattan but aren’t sure which area to choose, here’s an overview of the best neighborhoods in Manhattan:

• Upper East Side: The Upper East Side epitomizes elegance and sophistication. This area is most famously known for its luxurious brownstones, upscale boutiques, and proximity to world-class landmarks like The Met and Central Park.
• Greenwich Village: Greenwich Village is a hub for creatives and free spirits. This bohemian and relaxed area boasts charming cobblestone streets, a lively art scene, and endless dining and entertainment options.
• Upper West Side: The Upper West Side offers a quieter and slower-paced environment compared to other neighborhoods. Located on the edge of Central Park, this area is perfect for those seeking tree-lined streets and a peaceful retreat from the city hustle and bustle.
• Harlem: Harlem is one of the more affordable neighborhood options in Manhattan. Rich in history and culture, this unique area is known for its selection of soul food, famous entertainment venues like the Apollo Theater, and infectious energy fueled by a love for music.

Brooklyn

Next, let’s move on to Brooklyn: Manhattan’s edgier, trendier, and somewhat more affordable neighbor across the East River. Home to over 2.6 million residents, Brooklyn has evolved from being Manhattan’s cheaper alternative to a populous and sought-after borough in its own right.

About the Brooklyn lifestyle

Brooklyn offers a more relaxed and slower-paced lifestyle compared to Manhattan. However, that doesn’t mean it lacks excitement—especially in the food, art, and cultural departments. This borough truly offers the perfect balance of urban thrills and laid-back living, which explains why it’s become increasingly popular among New York City renters.

Cost of living in Brooklyn

While Brooklyn is more affordable than Manhattan, it’s still pricier than some expect. Monthly rent averages $2,864, but the rich variety of neighborhoods makes it possible to find something within budget. This area also has strong walkability and public transit access, helping renters save on commuting costs as well.

Depending on your living arrangement, here’s what you can expect for rent in Brooklyn:

• Studio: $2,579/month for 440 Sq Ft
• One bedroom: $2,864/month for 544 Sq Ft
• Two bedroom: $3,838/month for 721 Sq Ft
• Three bedroom: $4,394/month for 885 Sq Ft

Best neighborhoods in Brooklyn

You’ll get a different taste of Brooklyn in each of its unique residential areas. Whether you’re into art, food, or nightlife, there’s definitely a Brooklyn neighborhood that will check all your boxes. Here are some of our top picks:

• Williamsburg: If you’re a creative at heart, Williamsburg could be your spot. Here, you’ll be at the center of all the trends – whether it be what’s new in fashion, food, or art. Not to mention, you’ll also be front row to breathtaking skyline views of the East River.
• Park Slope:  Park Slope is a great option for families and young professionals alike. This charming, tree-lined community is close to excellent schools, accessible public transit, and expansive parks like the famous Prospect Park. Sitting in the neighborhood’s heart is Union Hall, a famous bar, restaurant, and live music and comedy venue.
• DUMBO: Short for ‘Down Under the Manhattan Bridge Overpass,’ DUMBO is where Manhattan and Brooklyn collide. This area boasts an industrial and commercial vibe, full of old warehouses that now stand as art galleries, tech startups, and trendy eateries.
• Bushwick: Many New Yorkers deem Bushwick the ‘coolest neighborhood in the city.’ Here, you can’t go one step without coming across captivating local art, packed bars and restaurants, or trendy boutiques or thrift stores.

Queens

Queens is known as a true melting pot, as it’s home to residents, cuisines, and cultural staples from all parts of the world. Of its 2.3 million residents, there’s not one race or ethnic group that holds a majority.  And along with being the most diverse, Queens is also the largest borough geographically, making it the perfect spot for those who value culture, diversity, and space.

About the Queens lifestyle

Living in Queens offers a quieter, more suburban feel than Brooklyn or Manhattan. However, that doesn’t mean it’s short of excitement and adventure. The area’s cultural diversity brings a rich variety of food, art, and entertainment options, which tastefully complement its peaceful residential areas.

Cost of living in Queens

The average cost of rent in Queens is $3,128, offering a mid-price point between Manhattan and Brooklyn. If you err on neither the conservative nor frivolous side of spending, Queens may be a happy medium for you. Compared to some other boroughs, you’ll definitely get more bang for your buck. Plus, you won’t have to sacrifice city access, as you’ll only be an inexpensive, 20-minute subway ride away from Manhattan.

Best neighborhoods in Queens

Queens’ residential areas reflect its diversity and flare. While some areas provide a taste of suburbia, others embody the thrill and organized chaos of city living. Here are some popular neighborhoods in Queens to consider:

• Astoria: Astoria is categorized by its quick Manhattan commutes, stunning East River views, and youthful energy fueled by ambition and a zest for life. The area is also known for its namesake park, which boasts hiking trails and basketball courts and brings a touch of nature to the concrete jungle.
• Long Island City: Long Island City is another commuter’s paradise, as it is just one subway stop from Midtown Manhattan and the Upper East Side. This waterfront neighborhood can be distinguished by its industrial landscape, with many apartments thoughtfully repurposed from historic manufacturing buildings.
• Forest Hills: If you thrive in the suburbs but still want a taste of city living, Forest Hills may be for you. This area offers a suburban feel with quaint row houses, tree-lined trees, and sprawling greenspaces like Forest Park.
• Kew Gardens: Found in the heart of Queens, Kew Gardens is one of the most beloved neighborhoods in the area. Here, you’ll find spacious apartments with neo-Tudor architecture, lush green spaces like Maple Grove Park, and easy access to the Long Island Railroad and express subway lines.

The Bronx

Famously known as the home to the New York Yankees and the birthplace of hip-hop, the Bronx has no shortage of cultural significance. Though it’s not considered the most popular borough, the Bronx still houses over 1.4 million residents, many of whom came for the more affordable housing, sprawling green spaces, and, of course, cultural attractions like Yankee Stadium, the Bronx Zoo, and more.

About the Bronx lifestyle

The Bronx is known to have less of an urban feel than other nearby boroughs. Much of this region is residential, with streets lined with classic pre-war apartments and brownstones. Residents here enjoy a quieter pace of life and rely on quick commutes into Manhattan for urban thrills. However, as we just mentioned, the Bronx still has its fair share of notable landmarks and experiences, particularly when it comes to sporting events or recreational activities.

Cost of living in the Bronx

The Bronx is the most affordable borough on our list so far. With an average rent of $1,628 per month, this area offers significantly more savings than other options. However, that doesn’t mean its residential options lack amenities, convenience, and other sought-after features.

When it comes to different apartment options, here’s what you can expect price-wise in the Bronx:

• Studio: $1,616/month for 448 Sq Ft
• One bedroom: $1,628/month for 521 Sq Ft
• Two bedroom: $2,083/month for 682 Sq Ft
• Three bedroom: $2,384/month for 783 Sq Ft

Best neighborhoods in the Bronx

The Bronx has no shortage of appealing residential areas. Consider the following standout neighborhoods if you’re interested in renting in the Bronx:

• Riverdale: Riverdale is known as a more upscale neighborhood with a suburban feel. Much of this area consists of single-family homes, top-rated schools, and a strong sense of community. This area is also widely recognized as one of the safest areas in the Bronx.
• Fordham: Fordham is widely recognized for its academic presence. Home to Fordham University, this area offers many off-campus rental options, along with other traditional property types.
• Kingsbridge: Found in the northwest part of the Bronx, Kingsbridge is famous for its range of transit options, extensive shopping corridor, and solid community feel. Its convenient location near Metro-North and the D subway train makes it the perfect homebase for exploring other parts of the city.
• South Bronx: South Bronx is an expansive residential area along the East River. Here, residents love taking advantage of waterfront views, proximity to Randall’s Island Park, and the charming community vibes that come with living on a smaller island within a giant city.

Staten Island

Staten Island is often considered the “forgotten” borough, as it is more remote than others and is only accessible by ferry or bridge. However, Staten Island still has much to offer, particularly when it comes to more spacious residences, expansive outdoor spaces, and affordable pricing.

About the Staten Island lifestyle

Staten Island offers a dose of suburbia within the city limits. Living here offers quite a different New York experience, as there’s much less congestion, noise, and hustle and bustle compared to other boroughs. Many of the Island’s 492,000+ residents enjoy a slower-paced lifestyle, surrounded by suburban culture, sprawling green spaces, and a strong sense of community.

Cost of living in Staten Island

Comparable to pricing in the Bronx, Staten Island boasts an average rent of $1,709 per month. However, while you can find a better bargain on an apartment, you may have larger commuter costs. If you work in Manhattan, you may have to carve out some funds for express buses or gas money for your personal vehicle.

Here’s a breakdown of how much apartments cost in Staten Island:

• Studio: $1,565/month for 456 Sq Ft
• One bedroom: $1,709/month for 677 Sq Ft
• Two bedroom: $2,376/month for 860 Sq Ft
• Three bedroom: $2,260/month for 1,103 Sq Ft

Best neighborhoods in Staten Island

Staten Island’s charm is reflected throughout its appealing neighborhoods. If you’re thinking of renting in Staten Island, check out the following areas:

• Great Kills: Sailing and sports are two things that come to mind when characterizing Great Kills. This area boasts a strong sense of community, a historic main street full of shops and restaurants, waterfront access to Great Kills Harbor, and some of the highest-rated schools in the borough.
• St. George: Known for its stunning views of Manhattan and Staten Island Ferry access, St. George has recently undergone an urban revival. Here, you can find a variety of apartments with water views and local hotspots like eateries, bars, and cultural landmarks.
• Tottenville: At the southernmost tip of Staten Island, Tottenville offers small-town charm with a strong sense of history. The quiet streets, Victorian-style homes, and proximity to nature make it ideal for those seeking a laid-back lifestyle.
• New Dorp: Located on the South Shore of Staten Island, New Dorp is known to be one of the area’s most walkable neighborhoods. Here, residents love strolling down the New Dorp Lane District, home to popular shops, eateries, and local businesses.

Explore Apartments for Rent in NYC on Apartments.com

Now that you have some background on each NYC borough, it’s time to start apartment hunting! Apartments.com offers a wide selection of rental listings in each borough, making it easy to find a home in the city that never sleeps. Use our advanced search filters to search by price, number of bedrooms, property type, and more to streamline your apartment search in New York City!