Showing Results for All Rentals in Shelter Island, NY

116 S Midway Rd

116 S Midway Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$44,000

3 Beds, 2 Baths

Controlled Access

(631) 953-0516
68 Peconic Ave

68 Peconic Ave, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$55,000

3 Beds, 2 Baths

Controlled Access

(631) 953-0516
4 Sheep Pasture Ln

4 Sheep Pasture Ln, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$23,000

3 Beds, 3 Baths

Controlled Access

(631) 953-0501
34 Country Club Dr

34 Country Club Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$95,000

4 Beds, 6 Baths

Controlled Access

(631) 953-0511
6 Summerfield Pl

6 Summerfield Pl, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$18,000

5 Beds, 2 Baths

Controlled Access
2 Hagar Rd

2 Hagar Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$37,500

4 Beds, 3 Baths

Controlled Access
14 Montclair Ave

14 Montclair Ave, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$25,000

4 Beds, 4 Baths

Controlled Access

(631) 953-0518
12 Cove Way

12 Cove Way, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$55,000

5 Beds, 4 Baths

Controlled Access

(631) 484-1098
6 Cobbetts Ln

6 Cobbetts Ln, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$40,000

5 Beds, 9 Baths

Controlled Access

(631) 953-0501
15 Montclair Ave

15 Montclair Ave, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$90,000

6 Beds, 5 Baths

Controlled Access

(631) 484-0991
9 Montclair Ave

9 Montclair Ave, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$35,000

3 Beds, 4 Baths

Controlled Access

(631) 953-0518
379 Ferry Rd

379 Ferry Rd, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
1 / 5
$53,000

3 Beds, 3 Baths

Controlled Access

(347) 827-5689
152 N Ferry Rd

152 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965
1 / 5
$40,000

3 Beds, 3 Baths

Controlled Access

(917) 545-6767
21 Peconic Ave

21 Peconic Ave, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$50,000

3 Beds, 2 Baths, 1,691 sq ft

Furnished Hardwood Floors Fireplace Smoke Free Deck
15 Montclair Ave

15 Montclair Ave, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$75,000

6 Beds, 4.5 Baths, 4,600 sq ft

Pool Smoke Free

(631) 484-0991
104 S Ferry Rd

104 S Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$30,000

5 Beds, 5.5 Baths, 4,040 sq ft

Pool Smoke Free

(631) 749-1155
3 Lakeview Dr

3 Lakeview Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$14,000

4 Beds, 2 Baths, 1,720 sq ft

Pets Allowed Pool Smoke Free

(631) 742-5165
26 Ole Buck Run

26 Ole Buck Run, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$3,500

3 Beds, 2 Baths, 1,238 sq ft

Pool Smoke Free

(631) 749-1155
5 Bay Ave

5 Bay Ave, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$18,000

3 Beds, 3 Baths, 1,675 sq ft

Pool Smoke Free

(917) 664-3017
28 Gardiners Bay Dr

28 Gardiners Bay Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$50,000

3 Beds, 3 Baths, 3,000 sq ft

Pool Smoke Free

(917) 664-3017

Condos New York Suffolk County Shelter Island

Find the Perfect Shelter Island, NY Rental

Other Rental Types

Shelter Island, NY Condos for Rent

Search for condos for rent in Shelter Island, NY on Apartments.com. With 20 available, you can find the right condo with the floor plan and amenities that fit your needs. When you rent a condo, you’ll likely rent from an individual owner rather than a property management company. This means units in the same building may have different features and layouts. Be sure to check out the photos and take a tour of the unit as you search for your Shelter Island home. There are some terrific Shelter Island neighborhoods with condos for rent, including Eastern Suffolk. If you’re looking for a budget-friendly condo to rent, try looking in affordable nearby cities like Shelter Island Heights, North Haven and Sag Harbor.