25 Houses for Rent in Shelter Island Heights, NY

80 Peconic Ave

80 Peconic Ave, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$42,000

4 Beds, 2 Baths

Controlled Access

(631) 953-0501
23 Tuthill Dr

23 Tuthill Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$95,000

3 Beds, 3 Baths

Controlled Access

(917) 545-6767
17 Stearns Point Rd

17 Stearns Point Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$72,000

5 Beds, 4 Baths

Controlled Access
15 Montclair Ave

15 Montclair Ave, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$180,000

6 Beds, 5 Baths

Controlled Access

(631) 484-0991
5 Penny's Path

5 Penny's Path, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$55,000

3 Beds, 2 Baths

Controlled Access
60 S Midway Rd

60 S Midway Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$33,000

4 Beds, 4 Baths

Controlled Access

(631) 953-0501
82 N Cartwright Rd

82 N Cartwright Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$45,000

4 Beds, 3 Baths

Controlled Access

(917) 545-6767
6 Summerfield Pl

6 Summerfield Pl, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$18,000

5 Beds, 2 Baths

Controlled Access
2 Hagar Rd

2 Hagar Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$20,000

4 Beds, 3 Baths

Controlled Access
12 Cove Way

12 Cove Way, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$55,000

5 Beds, 4 Baths

Controlled Access

(631) 484-1098
3 Wade Rd

3 Wade Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$20,000

3 Beds, 2 Baths

Controlled Access

(631) 953-0518
11F Petticoat Ln

11F Petticoat Ln, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$2,000

3 Beds, 1 Bath

Controlled Access

(631) 953-0501
2 E Brander Pkwy

2 E Brander Pkwy, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$95,000

3 Beds, 3 Baths

Controlled Access

(631) 953-0501
55 N Cartwright Rd

55 N Cartwright Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$30,000

4 Beds, 3 Baths

Controlled Access

(917) 545-6767
55 Shore Rd

55 Shore Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$85,000

6 Beds, 6 Baths

Controlled Access

(631) 953-0516
91 Shore Rd

91 Shore Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$40,750

3 Beds, 1 Bath

Controlled Access

(631) 953-0511
11 Tims Trail

11 Tims Trail, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$15,000

3 Beds, 2 Baths

Controlled Access
37 Tuthill Dr

37 Tuthill Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$85,000

5 Beds, 6 Baths

Controlled Access

(917) 545-6767
9 Country Club Dr

9 Country Club Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$22,000

3 Beds, 2 Baths

Controlled Access
23 W Neck Rd

23 W Neck Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$75,000

3 Beds, 3 Baths

Controlled Access

(631) 953-0511
53 N Cartwright Rd

53 N Cartwright Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$72,000

4 Beds, 3 Baths

Controlled Access

(631) 953-0511
3 Primrose Pl

3 Primrose Pl, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$70,000

4 Beds, 3 Baths

Controlled Access

(631) 953-0501
21 Peconic Ave

21 Peconic Ave, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$50,000

3 Beds, 2 Baths, 1,691 sq ft

Hardwood Floors Fireplace Deck
950 Blue Marlin Dr

950 Blue Marlin Dr, Southold, NY 11971
1 / 5
$20,000

4 Beds, 4 Baths, 3,200 sq ft

Dogs Allowed

(631) 834-0876
130 6th St

130 6th St, Greenport, NY 11944
1 / 5
$22,000

5 Beds, 2 Baths, 2,600 sq ft

(631) 834-0876

Houses New York Suffolk County

Homes for Rent in Shelter Island Heights, NY

If you're ready to find a single-family home for rent in Shelter Island Heights, NY, you've come to the right place. Whether you're looking for a 4-bedroom in the suburbs or a house in the city, you can find your perfect place on Apartments.com. To get started, use our custom filters to view the best rental homes in Shelter Island Heights. Take a look at houses with your preferred amenities, such as modern appliances, private garages, and fenced yards. Filter to view homes for rent with a pool, with utilities included, or with a finished basement. You can even search homes for rent by private owners. Click on any listing to find out more about neighborhoods, school districts, specific features, and view photos to help you picture how you'll settle into your new home.

Find your perfect home at the perfect price

Find a house for rent with all the modern features, space, and amenities you’ve been looking for, at a price point that works for you. If you're looking for stainless steel appliances, walk-in closets, and hardwood floors, you can browse an extensive list of updated homes for rent. In need of a short term stay? Enjoy the convenience of a fully furnished, move-in ready house. Or, if you’re saving on rent now to buy your first home later, search for budget-friendly rentals with the essentials, such as pet-friendly leases and in-unit washers and dryers. Remember that price varies by location. Average rent for a home in Shelter Island Heights is $52,230, ranging from $2,000 to $180,000. No matter your needs, you can find the best house for your lifestyle on Apartments.com.

Enjoy the space you’ve been searching for

Shelter Island Heights has a wide selection of rentals to fit your needs. Browse cozy 1-bedroom houses perfect for singles or couples, or filter for 3-4 bedrooms to accommodate a large family. If you're in need of a little more privacy, search for houses in gated communities, or browse homes with a basement and yard for extra usable space. Each listing includes square footage, lease information, and unique rental details. Ready to take the next step in your rental journey? Browse 25 Shelter Island Heights, NY houses for rent and find your perfect place.