East Flatbush

Brooklyn, NY

Background Image

East Flatbush - Brooklyn, NY

Area Guide

Share Guide
Niche Reviews Niche logo

Community is key in this commuter oasis

Mass Transit Diverse Community

East Flatbush is a quaint urban neighborhood that remains mainly residential, offering an abundance of attached family homes and apartments for rent. This neighborhood boasts a close-knit community with excellent proximity to major cities, attractions, and amenities. Situated ten miles southeast of Midtown Manhattan and just six miles southeast of Downtown Brooklyn, residents of this district have quick and easy access to some of New York’s liveliest cities.

Numerous subway stations and public bus stops are spread throughout town, so commuting is a breeze. In fact, the subway will take you all the way up to the Bronx! With small businesses and local restaurants around the neighborhood, your everyday conveniences can be taken care of without leaving town. After you find your perfect rental, test your taste buds with local cuisine at popular spots like Suede and Footprints Café. But if you’re looking for more variety when it comes to dining, shopping, and entertainment, just remember that big city living is just minutes from your potential new home in East Flatbush. East Flatbush is a great place to put down roots if you plan on commuting into the city, and you’ll appreciate the proximity to John F. Kennedy International Airport, located just 13 miles west of the neighborhood!

Explore the Neighborhood

The Newkirk Avenue subway station

Brick homes line the streets

Mass transit is easy to find in East Flatbush

A neighborhood street in East Flatbush

The Wyckoff House was built before 1641 and is now a museum

Rent Trends

As of December 2024, the average apartment rent in East Flatbush is $1,683 for a studio, $1,675 for one bedroom, $1,838 for two bedrooms, and $2,693 for three bedrooms. Apartment rent in East Flatbush has increased by 0.8% in the past year.

  • Studio

  • 536 sq ft

    Average Sq Ft

  • $1,683/month

    Average Rent

  • 1 BR

  • 373 sq ft

    Average Sq Ft

  • $1,675/month

    Average Rent

  • 2 BR

  • 542 sq ft

    Average Sq Ft

  • $1,838/month

    Average Rent

  • 3 BR

  • 760 sq ft

    Average Sq Ft

  • $2,693/month

    Average Rent

Transportation

85

Very Walkable

out of 100 WalkScore® Rating

If you enjoy walking, you’ll enjoy renting in this area! It’s a very walkable neighborhood.

91

Rider's Paradise

out of 100 TransitScore® Rating

Living in this area is considered a rider’s paradise, with world-class transportation.

63

Bikeable

out of 100 BikeScore® Rating

While there’s some bike infrastructure in this area, you’ll still need a car for many errands.

Reviews of East Flatbush - Brooklyn, NY

Niche Reviews Niche logo
3.2 78 Reviews

Nearby Resident

1 years and 9 months agoNiche Review

East Flatbush is a neighbor filled with many backgrounds and cultures. Many low income West Indian individuals live here. This area is full with many small businesses. However, gun violence and gang related crimes seem to be high in this neighborhood.

Current Resident

2 years and 11 months agoNiche Review

It's a very dirty neighborhood no street cleaning and people don't pick up after their pets. Trains are very far always at least a 30 min bus ride.

Former Resident

3 years and 1 months agoNiche Review

I moved to East 43 st when I was 6 years old. That was 67 years ago. I left the house when I was 19, 1967...just married. My family had a very nice home. There were 3 brothers and one sister. The area was a mixture because we had a row of private homes . And across the street they had apts. It was a safe to live. We went to the movies on Utica Ave, it was the Rugby theatre. We ate pizza next door at little Venice. We all went to ps 235, then Winthrop Jr high. And finally we went to Erasmus Hall Hs. When our Mom passes away, we had to drive from Ft Lauderdale, Fl to Brooklyn. We we so happy since the lady who bought our house was nice enough to let us in. Once more time for me, and my husband had a chance to see where I grew up and my little bedroom. The only problems in the area were because of my 3 naughty brothers. Otherwise it was a wonderful area to live in. Ilene Falley

Current Resident

3 years and 10 months agoNiche Review

I grew up in this area and its a very loud at night and no organic stores only a lot of fast-food chains.

See All Reviews on Niche.com

Points of Interest

Parks and Recreation

  • Wingate Park
  • Betsy Head Memorial Playground
  • St. John's Park
  • Brooklyn Children's Museum
  • Prospect Park Audubon Center at the Boathouse

Airports

  • John F Kennedy International
  • Laguardia

Top Apartments in East Flatbush

Houses for Rent in East Flatbush

Property Management Companies

Living in East Flatbush

History

-

East Flatbush was home to General George W. Wingate who oversaw the construction of the Brooklyn railways. During this time the neighborhood saw an in flux of island immigrants who make up most of today's population here.

The Wyckoff Farmhouse Museum on the southeast side of the neighborhood allows patrons to enjoy touring the oldest farmhouse in New York having been preserved for over 340 years. Several bike trails run behind the farmhouse on the land, and riders can get to the Brooklyn Bridge in 45 minutes.

There are no art galleries inside the East Flatbush neighborhood or major annual events, so residents regularly venture into neighboring communities.

Restaurants

-

East Flatbush houses many Caribbean-style restaurants which remain well-liked by the residents here. Regulars favor Suede on Clarendon Road. The restaurant serves modern Caribbean cuisine in a beautiful and relaxed setting. The decor in the restaurant appears quite unique and provides a relaxing environment to enjoy some of the best island food around. Try the signature salmon crab cakes and the jerk shrimp skewers. The menu also has options including braised oxtail and curried goat with jasmine coconut rice. The prices sit a little high compared to other Caribbean restaurants, but the food and service can't be beat.

Another local favorite, Trelawni Place Seafood Bar and Grill on Utica Avenue, features outdoor seating that draws in many customers especially in the warm months. Trelawni stays open until 3 a.m. on some nights and until midnight during the first half of the week. The menu has options like tofu and vegetable stir fry for vegans and grass fed jerk rib eye for meat lovers. The restaurant provides an upscale atmosphere with servers dressed in formal attire.

Residents of East Flatbush looking for a chill dining experience with outside seating go to Footprints Cafe on Clarendon Road. Home of the famous Rasta Pasta, Footprints serves all different types of island food. The restaurant has very reasonable prices and very friendly staff. This restaurant also stays open until 2 a.m.

Transportation

-

East Flatbush sits directly in the center of Brooklyn with major roadways in surrounding neighborhoods. The Shore Parkway runs along the south three neighborhoods away along the water. To the west, one neighborhood away sits the Prospect Parkway that runs north and south and connects to Interstate 278.

Residents who don't mind walking a block or two can take the subway. On the far west side of the neighborhood residents can find the 5-train and 2-train with tickets starting at $2.75 for a one-way ride.

Call for a cab or simply hail one with ease. Fares vary and start with a base price of around $8. Uber car services work well in East Flatbush with rates starting at $6 to go a few blocks. For those looking for a fancier Uber experience, the SUV premier service starts at around $60 and can go up to over $100 depending on the destination.

Crosswalks and bike lanes exist throughout the neighborhood, providing a safe environment for pedestrians and riders. Parking meters sit along some of the streets, making public parking for drivers easy and cheap at $1 per one hour of parking. Several parking garages in the neighborhood allow for more options, including Kings County Parking on Clarkson Boulevard and Central Parking right on the southwest tip of the neighborhood on Nostrand Avenue. Parking rates vary and usually start around $8 per hour and go up to around $25 per day.

Parks

-

Paerdegat Park on East 40th Street serves as East Flatbush's main park. The park features a clean and modern playground for children of all ages that remains fenced in to keep kids away from the street. Basketball and handball courts can lie within the park. Public restrooms and spray showers are located near the playground equipment as well. The park's renovation saw an addition of outside chess tables and a baseball field. The park remains free of charge, and leashed dogs are permitted in some areas.

A few blocks to the east on East 57th Street residents enjoy the Harry Maze Playground and park. The park features a modern and clean playground for children as well as basketball and handball courts. Spray showers are available near the public restrooms with fitness equipment for adults located nearby. The park costs nothing, and leashed dogs are permitted.

No annual events take place in either of the two small parks located inside the neighborhood.

Cost

-

The cost of living in East Flatbush in Brooklyn runs higher than the city average, 29 percent higher than New York State and 120 percent higher than the national average. A typical one-bedroom apartment in the neighborhood rents for around $1,500 per month.

A beer at a local bar can cost anywhere from $3 or $4 to as much as $8 or $9 for a specialty or imported craft brew. The cost also depends on the establishment and runs cheaper during happy hour.

Gas prices in East Flatbush run about the same as New York City's average and about 25 percent higher than the national average.

Transportation remains a little higher than average compared to other neighborhoods in New York City because the subway sits just outside the neighborhood and not in it, so those choosing not to walk will have to pay more for Uber or a cab.

Shopping

-

Several boutiques exist in East Flatbush, including Chouchounette Boutique on the west edge of the neighborhood on Church Avenue. Regulars enjoy the shop because it carries apparel from up-and-coming independent designers from all over the world. Chouchounette carries handmade items and accessories not easily found at other specialty stores or boutiques.

A unique find in the East Flatbush neighborhood, AK Couture Boutique and Beauty Bar on Church Avenue carries handmade, one-of-a-kind pieces from independent designers, as well as handmade beauty and bath products. The boutique serves as a one-stop shop for men and women who want to beautify themselves without having to hop around the city. Store prices remain reasonable, considering a moderate amount of the merchandise and products come from artisans who handcraft their items.

Several grocery stores serve East Flatbush, such as Key Food on Church Avenue. Smaller specialty grocery stores and delis populate some parts the area. Many residents turn to Carib Food Market on Utica Avenue in the heart of the community for fresh produce and meats. Venture a few blocks west to find Greenmarket, a year-round farmers market on Cortelyou Road that is open on Sundays.

Search Nearby Rentals