Favorites
Saved Searches

Apartments For Rent
Houses For Rent
Condos For Rent
Townhomes For Rent
Help Center
Rent Calculator

Language

English Español

Favorites

New

Alerts

Manage Rentals Sign Up / Sign In

Search input

minimum Rent Input

maximum Rent Input

No Min
$2,000
$2,500
$3,000
$3,500
$4,500
$8,500

$2,000
$2,500
$3,000
$4,000
$5,000
$9,000
No Max

Only show listings with no broker’s fee

Beds

Select two tiles for min/max range

Baths

Specialty Housing

Housing Type

Student

Senior

Military

Corporate

Additional Specialties

Low Income/Income Restricted

Short-Term

All Universities

Select One

Pricing Type

Amenities

1-2 Months

3-4 Months

5-6 Months

Under 12 Months

All Filters

Price

minimum rent select combobox

maximum rent select combobox

Only show listings with no broker’s fee

Beds

Select two tiles for min/max range

Baths

Home Type

Home Styles

Specialty Housing

Housing Type

Lifestyle select combobox

Student Filters

All Universities

University select

Pricing Type

Amenities

Additional Specialties

Low Income/Income Restricted

Short-Term

1-2 Months

3-4 Months

5-6 Months

Under 12 Months

Pet Policy

Pet Policy select combobox

Move-In Date

Popular Amenities

Apartment Amenities

Community Amenities

Square Feet

minimum square feet to

maximum square feet

Rating

Show Only

Properties accepting online applications

Properties with move-in specials

Properties that are for rent by owner

Rooms for rent

Keyword

Keyword search, separate by commas.

Searching for student living options?

Select your school and find the perfect place nearby or on-campus.

All Universities

Pricing Per-Person (0)

Pricing Per-Room (0)

Pricing Per-Unit (0)

Individual Locking Bedrooms (0)

Private Bathroom (0)

Roommate Matching (0)

Shuttle to Campus (0)

Study Lounge (0)

Walk to Campus (0)

No results found that match your criteria

Showing results for

All Rentals in Menantic Colony Shelter Island - Shelter Island, NY

Search instead for

Matching Rentals near Menantic Colony Shelter Island - Shelter Island, NY

Showing Results for All Rentals in Menantic Colony Shelter Island - Shelter Island, NY

$37,500

4 Beds, 3 Baths

House for Rent

2 Hagar Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

New York Suffolk County Shelter Island

Popular Searches in Menantic Colony Shelter Island - Shelter Island, NY

Select Bedrooms

4+ Bedroom Apartments in Menantic Colony Shelter Island

Explore Property Types

Menantic Colony Shelter Island Houses for Rent

Find Specialty Housing

Menantic Colony Shelter Island Cheap Apartments

Luxury Apartments for Rent in Menantic Colony Shelter Island, Shelter Island, NY

You searched for apartments in Menantic Colony Shelter Island. Let Apartments.com help you find your perfect fit. Click to view any of these 1 available rental units in Shelter Island to see photos, reviews, floor plans and verified information about schools, neighborhoods, unit availability and more. Apartments.com has the most extensive inventory of any apartment search site, with more than 1 million currently available apartments for rent. You can trust Apartments.com to find your next Menantic Colony Shelter Island rental.

Search Nearby Rentals

Nearby Apartment Rentals

Shelter Island Heights Apartments for Rent
Shelter Island Apartments for Rent
North Haven Apartments for Rent
Greenport Apartments for Rent
Southold Apartments for Rent
East Marion Apartments for Rent
Sag Harbor Apartments for Rent
Peconic Apartments for Rent
Orient Apartments for Rent
Cutchogue Apartments for Rent

Rentals in Nearby Neighborhoods

Eastern Suffolk Apartments for Rent
Silver Beach Apartments for Rent
Longview at Shelter Island Apartments for Rent
Shorewood Farm Apartments for Rent
North Haven Shores Apartments for Rent
Eastward Apartments for Rent
North Haven Manor Apartments for Rent
Reydon Shores Apartments for Rent

Nearby House Rentals

Homes for rent in Shelter Island Heights
Homes for rent in Shelter Island
Homes for rent in North Haven
Homes for rent in Greenport
Homes for rent in Southold
Homes for rent in East Marion
Homes for rent in Sag Harbor
Homes for rent in Peconic
Homes for rent in Orient
Homes for rent in Cutchogue

New Rental Listings

Shelter Island New Rentals

About Us Advertise Legal Notices Privacy Notice Equal Housing Avoid Scams Accessibility Rent Calculator USA Rent Trends Blog Canada Sitemap

© 2025 CoStar Group, Inc.

Equal Housing Opportunity

No Saved Searches

You must save a search in order to receive alerts.

Save your current search and get the latest updates on new listings matching your search criteria!

Matching Saved Search Criteria

Send a Message

Contact Property

First Name *

Last Name *

Email Address *

Move-In Date * enter move in date in the format: 2 digit month / 2 digit day / 4 digit year

Phone

I would like to...

Schedule a Tour

Request Application

Confirm Availability

Custom Message

Custom Message

Email me listings and apartment related info.

Submitting Request

Send a Message

Contact Property

Thank you! Your email has been sent.

Ready to Apply?

Good News! This rental is accepting applications through Apartments.com. Act now and your $ purchase will include 9 additional FREE application submissions to participating properties.

Or if you already have an account

Map Options

Map View

Default

Satellite

Nearby Point of Interests

Campuses

Restaurants

Transit

Neighborhoods

None

Travel Time

Search By Commute Time

Travel Time

Set a destination, transportation method, and your ideal commute time to see results.

Choose a destination

*Please enter your address or point of interest

Select transportation method

Ideal commute time

Set traffic type

Your Destinations

Powered by Travel Time