Montclair Village

We lived there for four years. We made all payments in advance. In our last month, we were asked to make the payment twice because of a mistake committed by their office staff. unsafe place to live, unprofessional staff.

Lived here for 2 years and it was amazing. Very well kept, nice staff, energy efficient appliances. Nice quiet area. Parking isn't bad - never once had an issue.

Easy access to all the shopping and a safe place to raise kids.

Top of my list to revisit for availability after my home sells.

Since moving in we have been so happy we made this move! Everything is so modern and well taken care of, and with the measures of security along with the location we are so comfortable! It's the last place you'll have to call home:)

Love this place!! Been here about a year now and love it! The parking can be tight at times but there is always garages available and room on the street. Seldin has a great relationship with Yale Security that has been great. Knowing that we have ARMED security within two minutes at all times is a great feeling. I don't really understand the "paper walls" comment.. We have had a family of 5 living next door for the last 9 months and haven't heard a peep through the walls. We love living here and would and have recommended it to all of our friends and family.

I originally moved here because they were offering such a great special. Updated nicely but not so great amenties for the price I would expect a pool deeper than 3 feet and a fitness center that was actually decent. Good luck working out without children running around. The fitness center is basically a play ground. I love kids but make sure you are okay with them playing every where in the parking lots, running up and down the hall ways. Theses aren't iscolated incidients this is my daily nightmare. There isnt a day I can't hear the ladies dog across the hall barking and crying nonstop. I consistently hear my neighbor above me snoring every night, having intercourse, walking around, flushing the toliet, doing laundry etc. I feel like I live with him and his girlfriend at this point. I have lived at a lot of higher end apartment communities but I have never experienced anything like this. I hate going home and who wants to feel like that. There is no peace and quiet I feel unconfortable in my own home. I have complained with staff who do nothing I have tried everything I can to get them to let me out of my lease. Talked with staff for 3 months about transferring to another unit to see if maybe it was just our building or our apartment. After months of waiting a unit finally comes available and then they want to tell me I have to pay a transfer fee. Told by the property manager he will contact me on a Monday after viewing the unit on Saturday. Its been a month I have heard nothing from him yet the unit is now on craigslist. I have five months left in this nightmare and I can gaurantee you I will never recommend this place, not even to my worst enemy. I usually dont let reviews influence where I decide to live but trust me Montclair is far from luxury.

I have had a great experience so far. I love my apartment because it's really open and roomy! I noticed the last review about parking and it can be tight if you get home late, but there are always spaces available in the complex. Other residents I've met as well as the staff have been really friendly.

Don't move here if you have a car. It's not totally rented yet, but there aren't any spots in front of my building if I get back after 7. Sometimes you can find a spot at the club house (a considerable walk on a slippery, lumpy snow-packed parking lot). Lately, the entire lot has been full. Other than that, the apartments are very nice.