Cheap Apartments for Rent in Shelter Island Heights NY - 25 Rentals

8 Oyster Pt

8 Oyster Pt, Greenport, NY 11944
1 / 5
$4,000

2 Beds, 2 Baths

(631) 477-5990
5 Bay Ave

5 Bay Ave, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$7,000

3 Beds, 3 Baths

(917) 664-3017
103 S Midway Rd

103 S Midway Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$12,000

3 Beds, 3 Baths

(631) 953-0501
8 E Brander Pkwy

8 E Brander Pkwy, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$20,000

4 Beds, 2 Baths

(631) 953-0511
950 Blue Marlin Dr

950 Blue Marlin Dr, Southold, NY 11971
1 / 5
$20,000

4 Beds, 4 Baths

(631) 834-0876
131 6th St Unit 7

131 6th St Unit 7, Greenport, NY 11944
1 / 5
$20,000

3 Beds, 2.5 Baths

(631) 988-8193
130 6th St

130 6th St, Southold, NY 11944
1 / 5
$22,000

5 Beds, 2 Baths

(631) 834-0876
14 Montclair Ave

14 Montclair Ave, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$25,000

4 Beds, 4 Baths

(631) 953-0518
71 Gardiners Bay Dr

71 Gardiners Bay Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$26,000

4 Beds, 3 Baths

(631) 905-4339
26 Ole Buck Run

26 Ole Buck Run, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$28,000

3 Beds, 2 Baths

(631) 749-1155
55 N Cartwright Rd

55 N Cartwright Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$30,000

4 Beds, 3 Baths

(917) 545-6767
3 Crab Creek Rd

3 Crab Creek Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$30,000

3 Beds, 4 Baths

(631) 905-4339
17 Stearns Point Rd

17 Stearns Point Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$32,000

5 Beds, 4 Baths
6 Cozy Ln

6 Cozy Ln, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$32,000

3 Beds, 2 Baths

(631) 227-4947
7 Sandpiper Rd

7 Sandpiper Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$44,000

3 Beds, 2 Baths

(631) 905-4339
165 N Ferry Rd

165 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965
1 / 5
$50,000

3 Beds, 3 Baths

(631) 953-0511
21 Peconic Ave

21 Peconic Ave, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$50,000

3 Beds, 2 Baths
5 Penny's Path

5 Penny's Path, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$55,000

3 Beds, 2 Baths
16 Little Ram Island Dr

16 Little Ram Island Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$60,000

3 Beds, 2 Baths

(917) 545-6767
2 E Brander Pkwy

2 E Brander Pkwy, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$65,000

3 Beds, 3 Baths

(631) 953-0501
15 Montclair Ave

15 Montclair Ave, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$75,000

6 Beds, 4.5 Baths

(631) 484-0991
4 Sheep Pasture Ln

4 Sheep Pasture Ln, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$85,000

3 Beds, 3 Baths

(631) 953-0501
37 Tuthill Dr

37 Tuthill Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$95,000

5 Beds, 6 Baths

(917) 545-6767
23 Tuthill Dr

23 Tuthill Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$110,000

3 Beds, 3 Baths

(917) 545-6767
14A Heron Ln

14A Heron Ln, Shelter Island, NY 11964
1 / 5
$129,000

3 Beds, 4 Baths

(631) 953-0501

New York Suffolk County

Shelter Island Heights, NY Cheap Apartments for Rent

Whether you're on a budget or just looking to save, there are plenty of ways to find cheap apartments and affordable rent in Shelter Island Heights. Start by defining your list of apartment “must-haves.” What features can you not live without? If you want to live within walking distance to your favorite downtown locations, you may find that apartment size and upscale amenities are not as important to you. On the other hand, if you value space, access to community amenities, or high-end appliances, you may be willing to move farther out from Shelter Island Heights hot spots where you can afford more apartment for less.

How to Find a Cheap Apartment in Shelter Island Heights, NY

Rent in the city center tends to be more expensive. Try looking for budget-friendly apartments in neighborhoods farther from downtown. These areas offer mid-range prices and can still be close enough to everything you need. Try looking for areas of Shelter Island Heights that might have more available rental units than others. In places with higher vacancy rates, landlords may be more likely to offer cheaper rent to fill the space.

When Are Apartments in Shelter Island Heights, NY Cheapest?

If you want to find cheap rent in Shelter Island Heights, timing can make a big difference. Apartments are usually cheaper during the off-season, typically December through March. During this time, fewer people are looking to move, so landlords are often more willing to offer lower rent to fill empty units. Another good time to search is at the end of the month when leases are up, and landlords want to fill vacancies quickly.

Cheap apartments in Shelter Island Heights tend to go fast. Keep an eye on timing, neighborhood options, and special deals to score the best rental price.