Showing Results for All Rentals in Shelter Island, NY

$85,000

6 Beds, 6 Baths

House for Rent

55 Shore Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

(631) 953-0516
$85,000

5 Beds, 6 Baths

House for Rent

37 Tuthill Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11964

(917) 545-6767
$20,000

5 Beds, 3 Baths

House for Rent

70 S Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

(631) 953-0501
$55,000

5 Beds, 4 Baths

House for Rent

12 Cove Way, Shelter Island, NY 11964

(631) 484-1098
$20,000

3 Beds, 2 Baths

House for Rent

3 Wade Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

(631) 953-0518
$50,000

3 Beds, 2 Baths, 1,691 sq ft

House for Rent

21 Peconic Ave, Shelter Island, NY 11964
$30,000

5 Beds, 6 Baths

House for Rent

104 S Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
$20,000

4 Beds, 3 Baths

House for Rent

70 S Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
$100,000

4 Beds, 5 Baths

House for Rent

11 Deerfield Rd, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
More Rentals Near Shelter Island, NY

We found 16 more rentals that closely match your search.
$50,000

4 Beds, 4 Baths

House for Rent

76 Sunset Beach Rd, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

(631) 899-0108
$100,000

5 Beds, 6 Baths

House for Rent

76 Crescent St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

(631) 953-0516
$55,000

3 Beds, 5 Baths

House for Rent

33 Seely Ln, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
$200,000

5 Beds, 5 Baths

House for Rent

100 Cliff Dr, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

(917) 331-1234
$30,000

3 Beds, 3 Baths

House for Rent

15 Hamilton St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

(631) 725-4413
$195,000

4 Beds, 3 Baths

House for Rent

43 Hempstead St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

(631) 899-0321
$3,500

3 Beds, 2 Baths, 1,600 sq ft

House for Rent

324 5th Ave, Greenport, NY 11944

(631) 764-3847
$55,000

2 Beds, 3 Baths, 2,253 sq ft

Condo for Rent

123 Sterling St Unit 12, Greenport, NY 11944

(631) 553-6533
$30,000

4 Beds, 4 Baths

House for Rent

5 Suffolk St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
$26,000

3 Beds, 2 Baths

House for Rent

70 Bay View Dr W, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
$9,000

4 Beds, 3 Baths

House for Rent

28 Windermere Dr, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
$45,000

5 Beds, 4 Baths

House for Rent

4 William St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
$22,000

4 Beds, 3 Baths

House for Rent

27 Bay Ave, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
$180,000

5 Beds, 8 Baths

House for Rent

67 Hampton St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
$200,000

4 Beds, 2 Baths

House for Rent

30 Suffolk St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
$7,500

4 Beds, 3 Baths

House for Rent

5 Sunset Rd, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

New York Suffolk County

Shelter Island, NY Apartments for Rent Under $2,000

Searching for apartments in Shelter Island, NY? You’ve come to the right place. Apartments.com has 9 available rentals with photos, floor plans, reviews, and verified information about schools, neighborhoods, and more to ensure you find the perfect fit.

What are you looking for in a new home in Shelter Island? By defining your priorities, you can narrow down the perfect neighborhood and apartment type to suit your lifestyle using our filters. Personalize your search by number of bedrooms, popular amenities, specialty housing types, and even square footage.

When Is the Best Time to Rent in Shelter Island, NY?

While rental availability in Shelter Island can vary year-round, certain months tend to offer more choices or better deals. Spring and summer are busy times for renters, but you may find less competition during the fall and winter months. If you're looking for flexibility in move-in dates or specific deals, try searching toward the end of the month when leases are often coming to a close.