All Filters
Price
Beds

Select two tiles for min/max range

Baths
Home Type
Home Styles
Specialty Housing

Housing Type

Additional Specialties

Pet Policy
Move-In Date
Popular Amenities
Square Feet
to

Rating
Show Only
Keyword

Searching for student living options?

Select your school and find the perfect place nearby or on-campus.

Pricing Type
Amenities
Nearby
Nearby

No results found that match your criteria

Showing results for

All Rentals in Shelter Island, NY

Search instead for

Matching Rentals near Shelter Island, NY

Showing Results for All Rentals in Shelter Island, NY

Let Apartments.com find your perfect fit!

Let Apartments.com help you find your perfect fit near here. Whether you’re searching for a luxury two bedroom apartment or a cozy studio, Apartments.com offers a convenient way to search our extensive inventory of apartments near here to discover the place you want to call home.


Shelter Island, NY Rental Insights

Transportation

How transit friendly is Shelter Island, NY?

Transit options in Shelter Island vary, but overall, it has a transit score of 0.

Education

What is the top Elementary school in Shelter Island, NY?

In Shelter Island, you’ll find top-ranking elementary schools like Shelter Island School.

What is the top middle school in Shelter Island, NY?

Shelter Island is home to some top-ranking middle schools, including Shelter Island School.

What is the top high school in Shelter Island, NY?

Moving is tough for high school students! Look for Shelter Island apartments near top-ranking high schools like Shelter Island School.

What colleges and universities are in Shelter Island, NY?

If you’re a student moving to an apartment in Shelter Island, you’ll have access to SUNY Suffolk Co., Eastern, Connecticut College, and University of Connecticut.

Helpful Rental Guides for Shelter Island, NY

Explore More on the Rentverse

Search Nearby Rentals

New Rental Listings

Map Options
Map View
Default
Satellite
Nearby Point of Interests
Travel Time
Travel Time

Set a destination, transportation method, and your ideal commute time to see results.

*Please enter your address or point of interest