-
Monthly Rent
$1,138 - $2,532
-
Bedrooms
1 - 2 bd
-
Bathrooms
1 - 2 ba
-
Square Feet
650 - 852 sq ft
Pricing & Floor Plans
-
Unit 06Fprice $1,138square feet 650availibility Now
-
Unit 06Wprice $1,138square feet 650availibility Now
-
Unit 14Xprice $1,138square feet 650availibility Now
-
Unit 04Eprice $1,420square feet 650availibility Now
-
Unit 12Jprice $1,153square feet 852availibility Now
-
Unit 16Jprice $1,153square feet 852availibility Now
-
Unit 12Oprice $1,193square feet 852availibility Now
-
Unit 15Sprice $1,222square feet 790availibility Now
-
Unit 14Aprice $1,232square feet 790availibility Now
-
Unit 01Tprice $1,262square feet 790availibility Now
-
Unit 05Tprice $1,489square feet 790availibility Now
-
Unit 06Aprice $1,495square feet 790availibility Now
-
Unit 18Tprice $1,589square feet 790availibility Now
-
Unit 04Pprice $1,615square feet 852availibility Now
-
Unit 10Hprice $1,615square feet 852availibility Now
-
Unit 11Hprice $1,569square feet 852availibility Jan 5, 2025
-
Unit 06Fprice $1,138square feet 650availibility Now
-
Unit 06Wprice $1,138square feet 650availibility Now
-
Unit 14Xprice $1,138square feet 650availibility Now
-
Unit 04Eprice $1,420square feet 650availibility Now
-
Unit 12Jprice $1,153square feet 852availibility Now
-
Unit 16Jprice $1,153square feet 852availibility Now
-
Unit 12Oprice $1,193square feet 852availibility Now
-
Unit 15Sprice $1,222square feet 790availibility Now
-
Unit 14Aprice $1,232square feet 790availibility Now
-
Unit 01Tprice $1,262square feet 790availibility Now
-
Unit 05Tprice $1,489square feet 790availibility Now
-
Unit 06Aprice $1,495square feet 790availibility Now
-
Unit 18Tprice $1,589square feet 790availibility Now
-
Unit 04Pprice $1,615square feet 852availibility Now
-
Unit 10Hprice $1,615square feet 852availibility Now
-
Unit 11Hprice $1,569square feet 852availibility Jan 5, 2025
Select a unit to view pricing & availability
About Stillwater
Located in Murray, Utah, Stillwater Apartments offers a collection of one and two-bedroom apartment homes developed with modernity in mind. With stainless steel appliances, oversized walk-in closets, gas fire places and more, our homes are sure to accomodate every lifestyle. Our pet-friendly community boasts an array of extraordinary amenities, whether it's relaxing poolside and soaking up some rays on the sundeck, socializing with neighbors around the fire pit, or gathering with friends for a cookout using our barbeque grills.Situated near Fashion Place Mall with I-15 and I-215 close by, our location puts you at the center of everything.
Stillwater is an apartment community located in Salt Lake County and the 84107 ZIP Code. This area is served by the Murray District attendance zone.
Unique Features
- Gas Fireplace*
- Oversized Walk-in Closet*
- French Doors
- Full-Sized Washer and Dryer*
- Kitchen Pantry*
- Stainless Steel or Black Appliances*
- Mountain Views*
- Undermount, Double Basin Kitchen Sinks
- Modern Ceiling Fans with Lighting*
- Two Inch Blinds
- Coat Closet
- Garage*
- Kitchen Islands*
- Lounge Area with Gas Grills and Firepit
- Pet Friendly
- Designer Pendant Lighting
- Plush Carpeting in Bedrooms*
- Resident Rewards
- Wood-Style Flooring*
- *Features Vary by Apartment
- Additional Outside Storage
- Custom Two-Tone Paint
- Patio or Balcony*
- Vaulted Ceilings*
Community Amenities
Pool
Fitness Center
Clubhouse
Grill
- Maintenance on site
- Clubhouse
- Fitness Center
- Pool
- Grill
Apartment Features
Walk-In Closets
Fireplace
Ceiling Fans
Vaulted Ceiling
- Ceiling Fans
- Fireplace
- Kitchen
- Vaulted Ceiling
- Walk-In Closets
- Balcony
Fees and Policies
The fees below are based on community-supplied data and may exclude additional fees and utilities.
- One-Time Move-In Fees
-
Administrative Fee$200
-
Application Fee$50
- Dogs Allowed
-
No fees required
- Cats Allowed
-
No fees required
- Parking
-
Garage--
-
Other--
Details
Lease Options
-
12
-
Short term lease
Property Information
-
Built in 1986
-
456 units/3 stories
- Maintenance on site
- Clubhouse
- Grill
- Fitness Center
- Pool
- Gas Fireplace*
- Oversized Walk-in Closet*
- French Doors
- Full-Sized Washer and Dryer*
- Kitchen Pantry*
- Stainless Steel or Black Appliances*
- Mountain Views*
- Undermount, Double Basin Kitchen Sinks
- Modern Ceiling Fans with Lighting*
- Two Inch Blinds
- Coat Closet
- Garage*
- Kitchen Islands*
- Lounge Area with Gas Grills and Firepit
- Pet Friendly
- Designer Pendant Lighting
- Plush Carpeting in Bedrooms*
- Resident Rewards
- Wood-Style Flooring*
- *Features Vary by Apartment
- Additional Outside Storage
- Custom Two-Tone Paint
- Patio or Balcony*
- Vaulted Ceilings*
- Ceiling Fans
- Fireplace
- Kitchen
- Vaulted Ceiling
- Walk-In Closets
- Balcony
| Monday | 9am - 6pm |
|---|---|
| Tuesday | 9am - 6pm |
| Wednesday | 9am - 6pm |
| Thursday | 9am - 6pm |
| Friday | 9am - 6pm |
| Saturday | 10am - 5pm |
| Sunday | Closed |
Just minutes down I-15 from Salt Lake City, Murray is a large suburban community in the shadow of the Wasatch Mountains. Home to over 50,000 people, Murray balances a thriving business sector, quiet residential neighborhoods, and the charms of a timeless mountain town. The historic Iris Theatre and Murray Theatre are still active venues hosting popular performances year-round, and the larger Maverik Center and Hale Centre Theatre sit just to the northwest of town, providing terrific entertainment options for locals.
Rail service from Murray Central Station will get you into Downtown Salt Lake City in just 12 minutes, making it a great spot for commuters. The nearby mountains offer endless opportunities for outdoor activities any time of the year, from hiking and biking in the summer to shredding the ski slopes in the winter.
Learn more about living in Murray| Colleges & Universities | Distance | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Colleges & Universities | Distance | ||
| Drive: | 5 min | 2.3 mi | |
| Drive: | 12 min | 5.8 mi | |
| Drive: | 15 min | 7.3 mi | |
| Drive: | 20 min | 9.9 mi |
Transportation options available in Murray include Murray Central, located 2.1 miles from Stillwater. Stillwater is near Salt Lake City International, located 14.6 miles or 21 minutes away, and Provo Municipal, located 39.9 miles or 53 minutes away.
| Transit / Subway | Distance | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Transit / Subway | Distance | ||
|
|
Drive: | 5 min | 2.1 mi |
|
|
Drive: | 7 min | 2.8 mi |
|
|
Drive: | 7 min | 2.9 mi |
|
|
Drive: | 9 min | 3.7 mi |
|
|
Drive: | 11 min | 4.2 mi |
| Commuter Rail | Distance | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Commuter Rail | Distance | ||
|
|
Drive: | 14 min | 9.2 mi |
|
|
Drive: | 17 min | 10.7 mi |
|
|
Drive: | 18 min | 12.0 mi |
|
|
Drive: | 20 min | 12.6 mi |
|
|
Drive: | 26 min | 19.2 mi |
| Airports | Distance | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Airports | Distance | ||
|
Salt Lake City International
|
Drive: | 21 min | 14.6 mi |
|
Provo Municipal
|
Drive: | 53 min | 39.9 mi |
Time and distance from Stillwater.
| Shopping Centers | Distance | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Shopping Centers | Distance | ||
| Walk: | 5 min | 0.3 mi | |
| Walk: | 8 min | 0.4 mi | |
| Drive: | 3 min | 1.1 mi |
| Parks and Recreation | Distance | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Parks and Recreation | Distance | ||
|
Wheeler Historic Farm
|
Drive: | 3 min | 1.4 mi |
|
Solitude Mountain Resort
|
Drive: | 8 min | 4.2 mi |
|
Conservation Garden Park
|
Drive: | 13 min | 6.3 mi |
|
Jordan River Parkway
|
Drive: | 13 min | 6.5 mi |
|
Tracy Aviary
|
Drive: | 17 min | 8.2 mi |
| Hospitals | Distance | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Hospitals | Distance | ||
| Drive: | 4 min | 1.8 mi | |
| Drive: | 7 min | 3.3 mi | |
| Drive: | 10 min | 5.7 mi |
| Military Bases | Distance | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Military Bases | Distance | ||
| Drive: | 18 min | 13.0 mi |
Property Ratings at Stillwater
Stillwater continues to be a good place to live. We haven’t had any problems, and we love taking our son to the pond to see the ducks. Proximity to stores is also very convenient
Property Manager at Stillwater, Responded To This Review
We are humbled by your praise, as our care and concern for our residents takes priority over all else. Thank you!
Been pretty good so far. We love our cute little place. Something’s could be improved of course but over all we love where we live. Love living so central to everything
Property Manager at Stillwater, Responded To This Review
Daniel, we are delighted to receive your review and know you are enjoying your cozy apartment home and our convenient location. Our team has a continuous improvement mindset and welcomes suggestions on changes that might further elevate your experience. Please reach out anytime we can help.
It's a decent community. A bit frustrated that my parking spot is so far from my apartment but I love the layout it is nice and quiet. A little outdated but cozy
Property Manager at Stillwater, Responded To This Review
Shaniya, thank you for sharing your experience in our peaceful community. We are glad you find your apartment home comfortable, but we regret your disappointment with the location of your parking spot. Our team will note this and welcomes you to stop by to speak with us. We are here to help whenever we can.
Beautiful property! I love how easy it is to take my dog out and enjoy the weather! The pond with the ducks and turtle are such a fun addition!
Property Manager at Stillwater, Responded To This Review
It is terrific to know that you have had a positive experience in our community! Thank you for taking the time to let us know.
It's peaceful living across the street from cemetery. And I enjoy my neighbors and having a duck pond. It's just an all peaceful place to live
Property Manager at Stillwater, Responded To This Review
Our team works hard to provide an outstanding experience for our residents, and it is wonderful to see that you are satisfied with our efforts! Thank you.
Good place to live nice friendly staff. relaxing area to walk your dog and chill by the pond and watch the ducks. Located by a little shopping mall that's very convenient.
Property Manager at Stillwater, Responded To This Review
It is terrific to know that you have had a positive experience in our community! Thank you for taking the time to let us know.
Pretty good! There is a slight sewage-y smell that I can’t get rid of though ?? there was also a bird living in the dryer vent, but they helped me get all of that handled super quick and were really nice about it too :)
Property Manager at Stillwater, Responded To This Review
It is nice to know our prompt team has impressed you with our signature top-notch service! We are always here to help, so please give us a call or stop by our office if we may ever be of service.
So far, so good. Was a little disappointed with the kitchen appliances though , they were a lot older than what was shown in virtual walk through.
Property Manager at Stillwater, Responded To This Review
Your happiness is always our goal! We appreciate your support.
I feel like maintenance is a little slow and non existent with requests. When we moved in there were things that were missing and still broken and we have yet to hear back from anyone that those things would be getting fixed. Very disappointing. :(
Property Manager at Stillwater, Responded To This Review
Aliya, thank you for making us aware of your concerns with our maintenance service. We are eager to help you feel more at ease in your home and our community overall, so please stop by our office or give us a call for further assistance.
Good place too stay nice staff friendly and conveniently located nice area too walk your dog with a pond and ducks work out room and swimming pool
Property Manager at Stillwater, Responded To This Review
We are delighted to see your outstanding review. Our team loves providing an exceptional experience to our residents.
All around a good place to live! They're always so friendly, and super nice to our kids. Maintenance is also quick to respond and repair when needed.
Property Manager at Stillwater, Responded To This Review
We are humbled by your praise, as our care and concern for our residents takes priority over all else. Thank you!
Jakayla was so helpful through the entire onboarding process. In fact, every team member I interacted with were helpful and professional. Thank you!
Property Manager at Stillwater, Responded To This Review
Your comfort and satisfaction are our priorities, and we are glad it shows! Thank you.
We’ve loved living here! Nice and quiet in a good area! Property managers are great to work with and our maintenance requests are responded to promptly!
Property Manager at Stillwater, Responded To This Review
Home is where the heart is, so we are elated that yours is worthy of so many stars. We are honored to provide such comfort to you.
It’s been a good experience living here so far; I can’t wait for better spring weather so we can really enjoy taking the baby over to the duck pond
Property Manager at Stillwater, Responded To This Review
It is indeed our pleasure to provide an outstanding place for you to call home! If you need anything at all, please feel free to reach out.
I've lived at the complex for 2 years and for the most part, it has been great. My girlfriend and I had our cars broken into and there are always tweakers wandering around the parking lot. But, I have had a pretty good experience and the staff has always been super friendly and helpful. I would recommend this complex to rent from.
Property Manager at Stillwater, Responded To This Review
We strive to provide a true haven for our residents to enjoy. Thank you for recognizing our efforts with your outstanding rating!
I have enjoyed living here. I also appreciate the discount at EOS Fitness next door to the complex. Looking forward to the pool opening for summer this year.
Property Manager at Stillwater, Responded To This Review
We are pleased that you shared your positive experience here! Please reach out if we can assist you with anything.
It's been nice quite, all the management have been polite and helpful. Very conveniently located. The fact that they except flex pay has been very benificial.
Property Manager at Stillwater, Responded To This Review
We are truly honored that you hold our community in such high esteem! Thank you for letting us know.
It’s been great so far, they are fairly easy to get in contact with. dog friendly close to an elementary school, grocery store gym etc. definitely a reasonable apartment complex.
Property Manager at Stillwater, Responded To This Review
Home is where the heart is, so we are elated that yours is worthy of so many stars. We are honored to provide such comfort to you.
It's a quiet place to live, it's just people do not pick up there dog poop, so you cant really walk in the grass but other then that its peaceful.
Property Manager at Stillwater, Responded To This Review
Thank you for letting us know that you feel so at ease in our community! It is truly our pleasure to provide you with a great home.
The office staff is friendly. Washer and dryer in-unit are serviced by apartment/company. Off of main roads but close to grocery, gym, Walgreens.
Property Manager at Stillwater, Responded To This Review
We are glad you have been impressed with our apartment community. Thank you for the many stars!
Just moved in recently, but so far things have been pretty cool here. We appreciate the quiet, despite the fact that it’s a pretty large community. It also seems really safe, with people frequently walking pets and kids playing around. We also really like the proximity to the gym, groceries, park, etc.
Property Manager at Stillwater, Responded To This Review
It is terrific to know that you have had a positive experience in our community! Thank you for taking the time to let us know.
The price for rent is good, but the property isn’t well maintained. It takes forever to get the work that you ask them to do done. When the maintenance people finally do come, they usually don’t fix the problem. So far, that has been my experience.
Property Manager at Stillwater, Responded To This Review
We are glad to see you have been satisfied with your apartment home, Patricia! We strive to show our residents capable and responsive service, and we are disappointed by your comments. We want to learn more and set up any additional services you may need, so please get in touch with our office at your earliest convenience.
This is a great place to live they are fast at responding to things that might be wrong they also are super understanding and knows that life happens sometimes and it is out of your control great place to live
Property Manager at Stillwater, Responded To This Review
We are delighted to see your outstanding review. Our team loves providing an exceptional experience to our residents.
Such a great community! I love the apartment and had a great experience with the move in. The property management has been very helpful. Sometimes are a little slow to respond but very helpful!
Property Manager at Stillwater, Responded To This Review
We are elated by your fantastic review! Our team is dedicated to your happiness now and for a long time to come.
I love this little community so far. It already feels like home. I can't wait to put on my favorite things in their new spots. The management seems to be on top of everything, and the maintenance guys seem really nice. My dog even really likes the area, and it seems like everybody cleans up after themself for the most part.
Property Manager at Stillwater, Responded To This Review
We appreciate your acknowledgment of our top-notch community! If we can do anything for you, please let us know.
We have been here for 2 years. We are going to sign our lease for another year. The office staff are friendly and helpful. Maintenance has been wonderful. The new gym is fantastic the equipment is great. It's a nice place to call home.
Property Manager at Stillwater, Responded To This Review
How nice to receive your applause for our efforts! We are here for you.
I've been having problems with my water heater for about 3 weeks now. I've put in about 5 maintenance requests. They have come out and relit the pilot light multiple times. It continues to go out once if not 2-3 times a day. I've told maintenance that they need to replace the water heater or the pilot assembly. They have done absolutely NOTHING to fix the problem!! Totally unacceptable and I most definitely will not be renewing my lease!!
Property Manager at Stillwater, Responded To This Review
Curtis, we appreciate your taking the time to share your experience. Our team aims to provide well-maintained equipment and apologizes if our previous service visits have not resolved the water heater concern. Please call or stop by our office to speak with us directly about addressing this matter. Thank you.
Every thing went smooth moving in. There are a few things that need to be fixed. I did not actually get to see the apartment before I got to move in so I was shocked about not having a lot of storage space. Other than that I think I will love it here.
Property Manager at Stillwater, Responded To This Review
Sheri, it is so great to know that you are looking forward with excitement to your future with us! Thank you for choosing us and for letting us know about your maintenance needs. We will be happy to take care of those right away. Please let us know at the office how we can be here for you.
It's nice living here so far, It's located in a such a convenient area, close enough to cool restaurants and bars. The ducks the live by the pond is one of the main selling points that brought me here. It's delightful to hear them quacking away in the mornings.
Property Manager at Stillwater, Responded To This Review
Thank you for letting us know that you think so highly of our community!
I have lived here almost 4 years. Have not had any major issues. Management has changed for the better since I have been here. We have a new gym area that I am excited to try out!
Property Manager at Stillwater, Responded To This Review
We appreciate your validation of our efforts to provide a wonderful community for our valued residents!
Overall nice and friendly clean apartment like the environment and happy to know that they are pet friendly easily found and conveniently located
Property Manager at Stillwater, Responded To This Review
We put our efforts into making our community feel like home for our residents, so it means a lot to know our efforts have made a meaningful impact on your experience!
Maintenance is always quick to respond, the property is beautiful, and I only deduct a star because management goes through a terrible service for their appliance repair.
Property Manager at Stillwater, Responded To This Review
Thank you for letting us know that you feel so at ease in our community! It is truly our pleasure to provide you with a great home.
The maintenance staff have always been helpful. The location is great. The office has had turnover but the current manager has always been helpful to me.
Property Manager at Stillwater, Responded To This Review
It is lovely to see that you are happy in our community! Thank you for sharing.
It is a nice community. I love being able to see the ducks swim in the pond from our front window. It has also been difficult to get the required maintenance that has been needed in our unit. We still don’t have our washer and dryer.
Property Manager at Stillwater, Responded To This Review
We are delighted to see your outstanding review. Our team loves providing an exceptional experience to our residents.
Friendly staff and neighborhood. The maintenance that used used to do inspections of the apartment is very professional. Also I love the location of the premises. A lot of stores gyms etc near by
Property Manager at Stillwater, Responded To This Review
It is terrific to know that you have had a positive experience in our community! Thank you for taking the time to let us know.
Good place, good community, fast processes, clean apartment. Everything is close, very convenient. Freeway, store and health care are all around
Property Manager at Stillwater, Responded To This Review
We strive to provide a true haven for our residents to enjoy. Thank you for recognizing our efforts with your outstanding rating!
It’s been really great living here. The maintenance is good and the management is great in the office. Happy holidays to everyone and hope everybody has a good new year
Property Manager at Stillwater, Responded To This Review
Your fantastic rating indicates that our efforts to provide a high-quality living experience have been fruitful. It is much appreciated!
I love my place so far. Neighbors are great. Had no problems so far, just wish we had an apartment facing the sun to get more sunlight. Overall it’s been good
Property Manager at Stillwater, Responded To This Review
Thank you for sharing your satisfaction with our community! If we can do anything for you, please let us know.
The apartments are nice, they are in a very good area, what I like most about the people who work in the Office, they are very friendly and patient, very good customer service.
Property Manager at Stillwater, Responded To This Review
We appreciate your acknowledgment of our top-notch community! If we can do anything for you, please let us know.
Only been here about a month , staff is super kind . They were super helpful and understanding with the move in process and are very time efficient
Property Manager at Stillwater, Responded To This Review
It is a lovely day when we know a resident is truly comfortable and satisfied in their living experience here. Thank you!
I love it here. The office is so nice. They’re patient and understanding of residents, which is something I appreciate. Maintenance is amazing and I love swimming in the summer.
Property Manager at Stillwater, Responded To This Review
We strive to provide a true haven for our residents to enjoy. Thank you for recognizing our efforts with your outstanding rating!
I love it here. Management and maintenance are easy to talk to and quick to fix issues, neighbors are friendly and quiet. I love the location and walking distance to anything I might need or want to do.
Property Manager at Stillwater, Responded To This Review
We are pleased to receive your vote of confidence! Thank you.
Been here almost 2 years now. Everything has been pretty good, except for my girlfriends and my car getting broken into. Other than that, I have no complaints. The office staff had a Halloween party and that was really nice!!
Property Manager at Stillwater, Responded To This Review
It is genuinely wonderful to know our community is such a good match for you. Thank you!
I’ve had a genuinely excellent experience living here. Some of the cabinets and floors are peeling up a bit, but maintenance has been great with the bigger issues. Considering the low price for our apartment, the community is beautiful and the living is great folks
Property Manager at Stillwater, Responded To This Review
Your happiness is always our goal! We appreciate your support.
I have lived here for about 2 weeks now, and everything has been great so far. We had a work order that was taken care of quickly, and everyone in the office is nice. The only thing is clearly some residents are not picking up after their dogs.
Property Manager at Stillwater, Responded To This Review
We are elated by your fantastic review! Our team is dedicated to your happiness now and for a long time to come.
Such a nice community. Love the area. Lots of things to do and places to eat that are very close. This past summer, really enjoyed the pool as well as the fire pit. Looking forward to being able to go to the gym once it opens as well.
Property Manager at Stillwater, Responded To This Review
We are delighted to see your outstanding review. Our team loves providing an exceptional experience to our residents.
My apartment is the cutest. This is actually my first time living in a 2 bedroom apartment of my very own. I can’t tell you enough how grateful I’ve been of Stillwater since I’ve moved in. Thanks so much!
Property Manager at Stillwater, Responded To This Review
We are glad you have been impressed with our apartment community. Thank you for the many stars!
This is a very quiet community at night. I appreciate that. I like that there isn’t a police presence all the time. The apartments are quite nice once all put together. The maintenance men are very helpful and work to help you understand how to fix things yourself.
Property Manager at Stillwater, Responded To This Review
We strive to provide a true haven for our residents to enjoy. Thank you for recognizing our efforts with your outstanding rating!
Very nice neighborhood and calm place Close to center roas for moving to south or north east and west. Food market and gas station close 2 yeas of living most of them peacefully
Property Manager at Stillwater, Responded To This Review
Hi Franz, we are delighted to know our location is just right for you and that you continue to enjoy your home with us! If there is anything we can do to enhance your experience, please be sure to reach out.
It has been great so far! Super nice and easy to talk to about if anything is happening! They were great with my moving and making sure that everything was good for me to move in
Property Manager at Stillwater, Responded To This Review
We strive each and every day to offer a comfortable experience in our community, and we are humbled by your high rating!
Stillwater Photos
-
-
Map Image of the Property
-
2BR, 1BA - The Cottonwood
-
-
-
-
-
-
Models
-
1 Bedroom
-
1 Bedroom
-
2 Bedrooms
-
2 Bedrooms
-
2 Bedrooms
-
2 Bedrooms
Nearby Apartments
Within 50 Miles of Stillwater
Stillwater has one to two bedrooms with rent ranges from $1,138/mo. to $2,532/mo.
You can take a virtual tour of Stillwater on Apartments.com.
What Are Walk Score®, Transit Score®, and Bike Score® Ratings?
Walk Score® measures the walkability of any address. Transit Score® measures access to public transit. Bike Score® measures the bikeability of any address.
What is a Sound Score Rating?
A Sound Score Rating aggregates noise caused by vehicle traffic, airplane traffic and local sources
5560 S Vine St
Murray, UT 84107
Responded To This Review