Are you a property manager or landlord who's experienced that sinking feeling when a tenant leaves your property in less-than-ideal condition? It's a common scenario, but there are ways to help you avoid this stress. How? By perfecting your verification process. In this guide, we will take you through essential techniques and tools every rental manager should have. From credit checks to income verification, let's review all aspects of tenant verification and why these methods are vital to the rental process.

The Cost of Irresponsible Tenants

The impact of an irresponsible tenant can be both financial and emotional. Late payments, property damage, and legal costs can quickly add up. But it's not just about the occasional late rent payment or minor damage here and there. The financial impact can be significant, affecting everything from eviction costs to repair bills and even loss of rental income.

Eviction Costs: More Than Just a Notice

Kicking out an irresponsible tenant isn't as simple as slipping a notice under their door. You're looking at legal fees, court costs, and potentially even the cost of hiring a sheriff to enforce the eviction. According to a study by TransUnion, the average eviction costs a staggering $3,500 and can take up to three to four weeks to complete. That's a hefty price to pay for a tenant who doesn't respect your property.

Repair Costs: Fixing What Shouldn't Be Broken

Then, of course, there are repair costs. Sure, some wear and tear is normal. However, irresponsible tenants can leave behind significant damage, from broken appliances to stained carpets and holes in the walls. These repairs can quickly add up, costing you thousands of dollars. And let's not forget the time and energy you'll need to spend finding contractors and overseeing the work.

Loss of Rental Income: An Empty Property Doesn't Pay

Finally, there's the loss of rental income to consider. If your property sits empty while you evict a tenant, make repairs, or search for new renters, you're missing out on valuable income. Every month without a tenant paying rent is a month where you're not making money from your investment.

The bottom line is that irresponsible tenants can cost you big time. But by implementing solid verification techniques, you can significantly reduce these risks, protect your investment, and ensure your rental business remains profitable.

The Importance of a Multi-Faceted Approach to Verification

The solution to dealing with problematic tenants lies in prevention. A thorough, multi-faceted tenant verification process is your best defense against the expenses associated with irresponsible tenants. This includes checking credit scores, verifying employment, contacting references, and conducting background checks. It's crucial to ensure you are leasing to responsible, dependable prospective tenants.

Remember, it's not just about filling vacancies—it's about finding quality tenants who will honor your property and meet rent obligations punctually.

What Is Rental Verification?

To find quality tenants to rent your property, it's best to contact an applicant's previous landlord to confirm their rental history; this is called rental verification. By talking to an applicant's previous landlord, you can check to see if they have been good renters, which can help you receive timely rent payments and protect your property. Below are steps on how to complete a rental history report for verification.

Step 1: Reach Out to Previous Landlords

Start by contacting your prospective tenant's previous landlord. They've been in your shoes and can provide firsthand insights into what it's like to have this person as a tenant. When reaching out, make sure you're clear about why you're calling and ask for their permission to discuss the tenant. It's a matter of respect and privacy.

Step 2: Ask the Right Questions

When speaking with your applicant's previous landlord or property managers, you need to ask the right questions to get the information you need about them. Here are some questions you might want to consider:

  • Did the tenant pay rent on time?
  • How did the tenant leave the property? Did they leave it in good condition, or was there significant damage to the property?
  • Did the tenant cause any disturbances, such as loud parties, or did they have frequent complaints from neighbors?
  • Would you rent to this tenant again? (This question can be telling. If a previous landlord would gladly have the tenant back, then this is a good sign.)

Remember, it isn't just about ticking boxes. It's about gathering as much information as possible to help you make an informed decision. After all, the more you know about your potential tenants, the better off you'll be.

The Verification Toolkit: Your Key to Successful Tenant Screening

As a property manager, your tenant selection process is crucial. It's like a defense system, protecting your property and ensuring a smooth rental experience. To help you in this mission, we've assembled a verification toolkit that includes the steps you'll want to take when verifying tenants, from the initial application review and credit checks to income verification, payment history, and reference checks.

Application Review: Your First Line of Defense

The application review is your first line of defense, providing you with an overview of the tenant. Here, you can gather essential information like their employment status, rental history, and reasons for moving. It's also a chance to check if they meet your basic criteria, such as income requirements and pet policies.

Credit Checks: Unveiling Financial Responsibility

Next in your toolkit is the credit check. This tool unveils a potential tenant's financial responsibility. Does the applicant consistently pay their bills on time? Do they manage their debt well? A good credit score can indicate they're likely to pay rent on time, too.

Income Verification: Ensuring Rent Affordability

Income verification is another essential tool. It's not enough that a tenant says they can afford the rent—you need proof. Pay stubs, bank statements, or even a letter from their employer can prove they have a stable income. Remember, a general rule of thumb is that their monthly income should be at least three times the rent.

Reference Checks: Getting the Inside Scoop

Finally, don't forget the power of reference checks. Think of this as getting the inside scoop directly from those who've dealt with the prospective tenant before. Previous landlords can tell you if the tenant paid rent on time, took care of the property, and behaved respectfully.

Remember, each tool in your verification toolkit is important. Together, they provide a full picture of your potential tenant, helping you make informed decisions. So, equip yourself with this toolkit, and bring confidence to your tenant selection and rental verification process.

Considering Criminal Background Checks: A Fair and Informed Approach

As a rental manager, you're always looking for ways to protect your property and ensure your tenants are reliable. That's where criminal background checks come in. Background checks can provide valuable insights, but it's crucial to use them in a fair and informed manner, keeping in line with housing guidelines.

Understanding the Role of Criminal Background Checks

Criminal background checks can shed light on a potential tenant's history. But remember, they're not about making snap judgments or unfairly excluding people. They're about understanding risks and making informed decisions.

Adhering to Fair Housing Guidelines

It's essential to adhere to fair housing guidelines when considering criminal background checks. These guidelines protect individuals from discrimination, ensuring everyone has an equal shot at housing. So, don't use these checks as a blanket policy to reject applicants with criminal histories. Instead, consider the nature, severity, and recency of their previous convictions.

Navigating the Limitations

Understanding the limitations of criminal background checks is also key. They're not foolproof—some records may be outdated or inaccurate. Therefore, it's wise to use them as part of a broader verification toolkit, including credit checks, income verification, and reference checks.

To summarize, criminal background checks can be a valuable addition to your verification arsenal. Remember to use them responsibly by respecting fair housing guidelines and acknowledging their limitations. Doing so will give you a comprehensive, fair, and informed approach to your tenant screening process.

Dealing with problematic tenants can be a headache, from late payments to property damage. Verification techniques act as a shield, helping you avoid issues. Thorough application reviews, credit, income, and reference checks offer insights for informed decisions. When used responsibly, criminal background checks provide valuable insights within fair housing guidelines. Understand their limits and incorporate them wisely. 

Tenant verification is an ongoing process. Selecting responsible tenants creates a positive environment and safeguards your investment. Continually refine practices, stay informed, and master rental property management.

A professional image of Helen Ann Wells holding flowers.

Helen Ann Wells

Hello, I’m Helen Ann Wells, a content writer at Apartments.com. With over two years of specialized experience writing in the rental industry, I am dedicated to providing comprehensive answers to your property ownership and management questions. My goal is to simplify your responsibilities as a landlord, property manager, or property owner, ensuring you have the insights needed to succeed.